Thinking Framework

Overconfidence

“Fools rush in where angels fear to tread.”

Description

Many people are overconfident of their ability to drive safely while texting.  

Overconfidence can trip us up in two ways:

  • Infallibility: we may believe that our knowledge and abilities are better than they actually are. This can lead us to underestimate the ways in which the problem system could behave in ways that we don’t expect (i.e., ignoring probability and uncertainty and their consequences). Evidence that we could be mistaken would be rejected because we’re already certain that we’re right. We may be sure that the actions we decide to take will be effective, so we may not consider the need to adapt to surprises.
  • Entitlement: we may believe that the problem can't be too serious because we're entitled to a good life. This attitude can arise because we may feel that humans are the most sophisticated life form, unjustified optimism, religious conviction, cultural influence, patriotism, and so on.

In either case, the result is that we might underestimate the problem and consequently fail to make the best decisions to deal with it.

Examples

Cromwell's Rule

In 1650, Scotland was loyal to King Charles II, and was certain of the religious and political basis of its belief. When conflict with England loomed, the Scots assumed that they couldn't possibly lose. Just before the battle, the English statesman Oliver Cromwell wrote to the Scots: “…I beseech you, in the bowels of Christ, think it possible that you may be mistaken…”. However, Scotland remained convinced of its infallibility and entitlement to victory.

The Scots were decisively defeated.

Nazi Germany repeated these mistakes. Hitler was convinced that the German people were entitled to a third reich (empire), and didn’t accept that Germany couldn't win World War II until Soviet forces were advancing through Berlin.

Blockbuster

In 2000, Blockbuster had the opportunity to buy Netflix for $50 million USD. Blockbuster turned down the deal because they were overconfident about their dominant market position and the security of their video rental system.

Blockbuster subsequently went bankrupt, and Netflix’s value in 2016 is in excess of $300 billion USD.

Driving

A large majority of drivers believe that their driving abilities are above average, and better than they really are. This leads them to underestimate the risks associated with speeding, texting while driving, tailgating, and so on.

In addition to impairing skills, alcohol and other drugs can cause overconfidence. This contradictory combination of effects contributes to numerous road deaths.

Climate Change

There is a lot of information about climate change available to everyone. After reading some of it, it's tempting for us to assume that we know enough about it to make confident judgements.

Some people are very confident that a scientific or technical solution will be found to stave off climate change. Belief in a ‘magic bullet’ risks deferring difficult political and economic decisions that are more likely to make a difference.

A sense of entitlement to a standard of living that requires substantial resource consumption and pollution discourages acceptance of climate change and the need to alter behaviour.

This section describes similarities and differences between this issue and related problem factors and thinking traps.

Probability and Uncertainty

Extreme overconfidence in our belief about what will happen closes our minds to probability and uncertainty, and the consequences of those difficulties.

Instinct and Intuition

Both instinct and intuition can oversimplify problems yet also give us a false sense of confidence that they’re correct.

Assumptions

Overconfidence can be expressed as assumptions: we might assume that we know more than we really do, and we might assume that we're entitled to a good life.

Overconfidence can cause us to make subconscious assumptions about specific issues and then treat those assumptions as facts. Instead, when issues are tricky, we should treat assumptions as potential errors.

Risk Factor Misjudgement

Overconfidence can result in various risk factor misjudgements.

We can underestimate the probability of bad outcomes by being sure that 'it will never happen to me'. More generally, treating optimistic assumptions as facts rather than probabilities or uncertainty can result in misjudging actual probabilities.

Overconfidence can also lead us to underestimate the severity of possible consequences. For example, we may be unduly optimistic that scientists will come up with something to fix the problem, or that our own actions will be  completely effective.

Confirmation Bias

Confirmation bias can create or increase overconfidence in our own abilities and entitlements.

Underconfidence

Overconfidence is the opposite of underconfidence. If we're overconfident, we might zealously deal with the situation. However, if we lack confidence, we might avoid doing so even when we should.

If overconfidence leads us to incorrectly believe that nothing needs to be done, the result (i.e., inaction) can be the same.

We need to find a balance between unjustified overconfidence and underconfident torpor.

Related Engine Processes

Later, we will describe a thinking framework that comprises multiple processes. This section points forward to the processes that deal with this page's topic.

Adaptation

If we are supremely confident that our actions (or inactions) will solve the problem, we won’t feel the need to monitor the situation and adapt if things don’t go the way we expected them to. When dealing with non-trivial problems, we should be mindful of the possibility that we may not get it right first time.

Further Reading

Cromwell's Rule (Wikipedia).

Dunning–Kruger effect (Wikipedia): tendency to overestimate one’s own ability.


To Do

Murdered Darlings

self-awareness qv and open-mindedness qv as related. "Nobody is infallible. We must all consciously question our preconceptions and strive to objectively evaluate alternative points of view. This is unnatural and requires effort."

Cromwell breaks Bayes' Theorem, because any amount of contrary evidence will be rejected.

'bull in a china shop'? Pic? Not a good fit: bull isn't overconfident; it just doesn't care. It may even WANT to damage the delicate system.

On This Page